Skip to Content

Should teeth be as white as eyes?

Teeth whitening has become an extremely popular cosmetic treatment in recent years. Many people strive for bright, white smiles seen on celebrities and in ads. But some take it too far, ending up with unnaturally white “chiclet” teeth. This raises the question: what is the ideal level of teeth whitening? Should we aim for teeth as white as eyes, or is there a healthy limit?

The Quest for Whiter Teeth

Humans are visual creatures, and we make instant judgments based on appearance. Studies show people perceive those with straight, white teeth as more competent, successful, and trustworthy. With the influence of media and celebrity culture, bright white teeth have become associated with beauty, youth, status, and health.

But how white exactly? Eyes provide a common comparison point. Somewhere along the way, eyes became an ideal benchmark for teeth shade. Advertisements started featuring models with teeth rivaling white eyeballs. The message was clear: the whiter the better.

This sparked a Whitening Revolution. Teeth whitening is now a multi-billion dollar industry expected to reach $7.4 billion by 2024. Whitening toothpastes, strips, trays, and professional in-office procedures promise to help people achieve gleaming Hollywood smiles.

Dangers of Extreme Whitening

But teeth were never designed to be as vividly white as eyes. Teeth naturally have a yellowish or ivory hue due to their internal structure. Enamel is semi-translucent and allows the yellowish dentin layer underneath to show through.

Here are some risks associated with extreme teeth whitening:

  • Tooth sensitivity – Whitening agents can irritate the nerves inside teeth, causing temporary but sometimes severe pain.
  • Gum irritation – Whitening gel touching gums can cause burning, redness, and swelling.
  • Tooth damage – Overuse of peroxide-based whiteners can break down enamel and make teeth prone to decay.
  • Unnatural look – Ultra-white teeth can look obviously fake and distracting.

Healthy Whiteness Range

So how can you lighten your teeth safely? The key is moderation and staying within the healthy range of whiteness. Here are some guidelines:

Whiteness Level Appearance Recommendation
Natural shade Slight ivory or yellowish tint No whitening needed
Mildly whitened Subtle lightening, no longer yellowish Good for mild staining
Noticeably whitened Definite white shade, slightly brighter than normal Moderate whitening but don’t overdo it
Unnaturally white Stark white and translucent like eyes Avoid – this level is unsafe

The sweet spot is somewhere between mildly whitened to noticeably whitened teeth. Your teeth should not match the white of your eyes or paper. Slight ivory shading is healthy and natural.

Gradual Whitening Is Best

It’s best to gradually lighten your teeth over time through lower concentration peroxide whiteners. Get professional advice to avoid over-bleaching and damage. And don’t forget to also keep your teeth healthy through regular brushing, flossing, and dental visits.

Moderately whiter teeth can help you look more vibrant. But chasing unrealistic levels of whiteness can do more harm than good. Stay safely in the healthy range of whiteness and remember your natural tooth shade is beautiful too.


While very white teeth are portrayed as ideal in media, teeth were never meant to match the intense whiteness of eyes. Attempting to reach this extreme level of whiteness can damage teeth and give an unnatural look. The healthiest range is mildly to moderately whitened teeth, staying safely between natural ivory and unnaturally stark white. Overall, moderation is key for a bright yet natural-looking smile.