Skip to Content

Which Maybelline lipstick is best?

By: Author Color With Leo

When it comes to choosing the best Maybelline lipstick, there are a few key factors to consider:

Types of Maybelline Lipsticks

Maybelline offers a wide variety of lipstick finishes and formulas. Here are some of the most popular types:

  • Matte lipsticks – These have a dry, matte finish that is often very long-lasting. Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink and Color Sensational Matte lipsticks are great options.
  • Creamy lipsticks – Creamy lipsticks provide full coverage with a satin finish. The Color Sensational Creamy Mattes and Creamy Matte lipsticks are smooth and hydrating.
  • Glossy lipsticks – For shine and moisture, go for a glossy lipstick like the Color Sensational Shine Compulsion lipsticks which give a brilliant glossy finish.
  • Sheer lipsticks – Sheer lipstick formulas provide light, translucent coverage. The Baby Lips Crayon Moisturizing Lip Color is a nourishing sheer lip crayon.
  • Liquid lipsticks – Maybelline’s SuperStay 24 offerings provide intense matte color in a lightweight liquid formula that lasts for up to 24 hours.

Best Maybelline Lipsticks By Finish

Here are some of Maybelline’s top lipsticks based on the finish you’re looking for:

Finish Best Maybelline Lipsticks
Matte SuperStay Matte Ink, Color Sensational Matte, Creamy Matte
Creamy Color Sensational Creamy Mattes, Creamy Matte
Glossy Color Sensational Shine Compulsion
Sheer Baby Lips Crayon
Liquid Matte SuperStay 24

Most Popular Maybelline Lipstick Shades

When shopping for that perfect lipstick shade, these are some of Maybelline’s all-time bestselling and most beloved colors:

  • Born With It – A neutral nude pink that works for many skin tones.
  • Touch of Spice – A natural, rosy nude that flatters without being overpowering.
  • Crazy for Coffee – A rich, warm brown nude that’s flattering on deeper skin tones.
  • Almond Rose – A soft pinky nude that brightens the complexion.
  • Stormy Sahara – A terracotta nude shade that’s perfect for fall.
  • Nude Nuance – A pinky beige that adds a subtle wash of color.
  • Clay Crush – A dusty, earthy rose shade that’s office-friendly but not boring.
  • Blushing Pout – A vibrant, blue-toned fuchsia pink that makes a statement.
  • Burgundy Blush – A deep wine shade that’s vampy yet wearable.
  • Ruby for Me – A rich, blue-red that flatters all skin tones.

Best Long-Lasting Maybelline Lipsticks

If you’re looking for a lipstick that will stay put all day without fading or transferring, consider these top long-lasting picks:

  • SuperStay Matte Ink – This ultra-matte liquid lipstick lasts for up to 16 hours.
  • SuperStay 24 2-Step Liquid Lipstick – Provides 24 hours of intense color with a comfortable matte finish.
  • Color Sensational Creamy Matte – This creamy matte formula delivers 8 hours of smudge-resistant wear.
  • Color Sensational Loaded Bolds – Bold, matte color that lasts for up to 8 hours.

Many of Maybelline’s matte lipstick formulas offer impressive staying power. The key is to prep lips properly with lip balm and liner to prevent drying and maximize wear time.

Top Rated Maybelline Lipsticks

Based on thousands of customer reviews, these Maybelline lipsticks consistently earn top marks:

  • SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick – This lip color earns rave reviews for its intensely matte finish and epic 16-hour wear. The shade range offers nudes, pinks and reds for every skin tone.
  • Color Sensational Creamy Matte Lipstick – Customers love the comfortable, lightweight feel of this creamy matte formula. The shades are richly pigmented and leave a bold matte finish.
  • Baby Lips Moisturizing Lip Balm – This hydrating lip balm comes in sheer tints and gives lips a boost of color and moisture. It’s affordable, cute and gets high marks from reviewers.

Reviewers praise the comfortable texture, extensive shade ranges, and affordability of Maybelline’s lipsticks. Many mention these are great dupes for higher-end lip colors at a fraction of the price.

Best Maybelline Lipsticks For Dark Skin

Those with rich, deep skin tones can rock nearly any vibrant shade. But here are some of the most complementary Maybelline lip colors for dark complexions:

  • Crazy for Coffee – A warm, chocolate brown with a creamy finish.
  • Born With It – A natural mauve-pink nude that doesn’t wash out dark skin.
  • Stormy Sahara – A burnt orange nutmeg hue that pops against deep skin.
  • Burgundy Blush – A lush wine shade that looks sophisticated.
  • Divine Wine – A bold, blue-red wine shade.
  • Mocha Ecstasy – A creamy mocha infused with orchid.

Darker complexions can pull off deeper, bolder lipstick hues without them being overpowering. Go for richer shades of berries, wines, chocolates and rubies.

Best Maybelline Lipsticks For Fair Skin

Those with fair skin need to avoid shades that could make them look washed out. Here are flattering Maybelline lip colors for lighter complexions:

  • Blushing Pout – A bright, cool-toned pinky fuchsia.
  • Born With It – A soft rose-mauve nude.
  • Nude Nuance – A pale peachy-pink nude.
  • Almond Rose – A dusty rose shade.
  • Touch of Spice – A natural, warm nude.
  • Clay Crush – A rosy brown with mauve undertones.

Fair skin looks best in lighter, brighter shades with a hint of color. Pinky nudes, mauves, peaches and plums are all great lipstick choices.

Most Moisturizing Maybelline Lipsticks

If dry, flaky lips are an issue for you, go for a Maybelline lipstick with a creamy, moisturizing formula. Top options include:

  • Baby Lips – Contains hydrating ingredients like vitamin E and coconut oil.
  • Color Sensational Creamy Mattes – Creamy, comfortable matte lipsticks that won’t dry out lips.
  • Color Sensational Inti-Matte Nudes – A matte lipstick infused with honey nectar for a hydrating feel.
  • Shine Compulsion – Conditioning lipsticks with a brilliant glossy shine.

Exfoliating and prepping lips with balm can also help combat dryness when wearing matte lipstick formulas.

Best Maybelline Lip Liners

Lip liner helps create the perfect lip shape and prevents feathering and bleeding. Here are top-rated Maybelline lip liners:

  • Color Sensational Shaping Lip Liner – Waterproof, long-lasting lip liner in a range of neutral and bold shades.
  • Lipstudio Lip Liner – Smooth, creamy lip liners for precision definition.
  • Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner – This gel eyeliner pencil glides easily and can double as a lip liner.

Using a liner that matches your lipstick shade will help it last longer. Go slightly darker if you want to define and reshape your lips.

Maybelline Lipstick Dupes For High End Brands

You can save money by choosing Maybelline lip colors that are dupes for pricier department store brands. Some dupes to try:

  • Born With It = Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk
  • Crazy for Coffee = MAC Whirl
  • Touch of Spice = MAC Taupe
  • Nude Nuance = Dior Addict Lip Glow
  • Stormy Sahara = Tom Ford Indian Rose
  • Divine Wine = YSL Rouge Pur Couture in Le Rouge

Maybelline’s extensive range of shades and finishes makes it easy to find budget-friendly dupes for luxury lipsticks.

How To Apply Maybelline Lipstick

Follow these steps for flawless Maybelline lipstick application:

  1. Exfoliate lips with a scrub to remove dead skin.
  2. Apply lip balm and allow it to sink in for 5 minutes.
  3. Outline and fill in lips with liner if using.
  4. Using a lip brush or directly from the tube, apply lipstick starting from the cupid’s bow and working outward.
  5. Blot lips with a tissue to remove excess.
  6. Apply a second layer for full opacity and color payoff.
  7. Finish with setting powder or clear gloss if desired to lock in the color.

These application tips will help your Maybelline lipstick look and last its best!

Conclusion

Maybelline offers an incredible selection of lipstick textures and shades at affordable prices. Top-rated favorites include the SuperStay Matte Ink for epic wear, Creamy Mattes for comfortable matte color, and moisturizing Baby Lips tints. Bestselling shades range from neutrals like Born With It to bolder colors like Ruby for Me. Prep lips properly and match shades to your skin tone for optimal results. With the right application tips and lipstick choices, Maybelline can give you a gorgeous palette of lip looks.