Skip to Content

What toner is compatible with HP Color LaserJet Pro M254dw?

The HP Color LaserJet Pro M254dw is a popular color laser printer that was released in 2017. It uses HP 305A cartridges including black, cyan, magenta and yellow toner. When these original HP toners run out, you have several options for replacement toners that will work with your printer.

Replacement Toner Overview

There are three main types of replacement toners available for the HP Color LaserJet Pro M254dw:

  • Original HP toners – These are made by HP and deliver premium performance, but are the most expensive option.
  • Compatible toners – Compatible toners are made by third parties to match the original HP toner specifications. They are more affordable but may have some variability in performance.
  • Remanufactured toners – Remanufactured toners are original HP cartridges that have been refilled and reused. They represent a middle ground in terms of price and performance.

When choosing replacement toners, you need to consider factors like print quality, page yield, and cost per page. It’s a good idea to research different brands and read online reviews before purchasing.

Original HP 305A Toners

Using original HP toners is the safest option to maintain optimal print quality and performance with your HP Color LaserJet Pro M254dw. The original cartridge numbers are:

  • Black: HP 305A (CF530A)
  • Cyan: HP 305A (CF531A)
  • Magenta: HP 305A (CF533A)
  • Yellow: HP 305A (CF532A)

Key features of original HP 305A toners:

  • Produce professional quality color prints
  • Reliable page yields up to 2,300 pages for black and 1,800 pages for color
  • HP ColorSphere toner for vibrant colors and detailed images
  • Works flawlessly with your printer right out of the box

The main downside of HP original toners is their premium pricing, costing 2-3 times more than many third party alternatives per page. But you can depend on them to deliver the same high level of performance that you’ve experienced with the included starter toner cartridges.

Compatible Replacement Toners

There are many compatible replacement toner cartridges available made by third party manufacturers to work in the HP Color LaserJet Pro M254dw. These offer significant cost savings over original HP toners. Some top compatible replacement options include:

Brand Black Cartridge Cyan Cartridge Magenta Cartridge Yellow Cartridge
LD Products LD-305A-BK LD-305A-C LD-305A-M LD-305A-Y
Toner Giant TG-305A-BK TG-305A-C TG-305A-M TG-305A-Y
INKO IK-305A-BK IK-305A-C IK-305A-M IK-305A-Y

Benefits of compatible replacement toners:

  • Significantly lower cost per page
  • Similar page yields to OEM cartridges
  • Many offer 1-year warranties against defects
  • Most match HP print quality and performance

Be sure to buy from reputable brands for best results. Avoid cheap no-name toner cartridges that could damage your printer. Carefully research user reviews before purchasing.

Remanufactured HP 305A Toners

Remanufactured HP toners for the M254dw are original used OEM cartridges that have been refilled and tested to work like new again. Top brands include:

  • Remanufactured by HP
  • LD Products
  • Clover Imaging Group

Benefits of remanufactured toners:

  • Cost savings over new OEM cartridges
  • Reputable suppliers stand behind their quality
  • More environmentally friendly than entirely new cartridges
  • Many providers offer warranties and money-back guarantees

Be aware that page yields may be slightly lower than original HP due to remanufacturing. Print quality is often very close to OEM standards if from a high-quality provider.

How to Choose the Best Toner

When deciding which replacement toner to buy for your HP Color LaserJet Pro M254dw consider these tips:

  • Check user reviews – Look for brands with overwhelmingly positive feedback for performance.
  • Consider cost per page – Calculate total cost of toner divided by yield to compare values.
  • Buy from trusted suppliers – Get toners from reputable retailers and manufacturers.
  • Look for warranties – Seek at least 1-year warranties for defects and performance.
  • Check for deals – Buying multi-packs or combo toner sets can offer additional savings.
  • Focus on quality – Don’t sacrifice print quality just to save money.

Taking these factors into account will help you find the best compatible, remanufactured or OEM toners for your needs and budget.


There are many high-quality replacement toner options available for the HP Color LaserJet Pro M254dw printer. While original HP 305A toners deliver the ultimate performance and reliability, compatible and remanufactured alternatives can offer significant cost savings while still providing excellent print quality and page yields.

Do some research to find well-reviewed toner brands that match your needs and budget. With the right toner cartridges, you can keep your M254dw printing affordably for years to come.