Skip to Content

Are all Goodwill colors the same?

Goodwill is a popular thrift store chain that sells donated used goods at affordable prices. One of the most recognizable aspects of Goodwill is their color-coded tag system used to price items. But does each Goodwill use the same color tags for pricing? Let’s take a look at how pricing works at Goodwill to see if the color tags are uniform across stores.

How Goodwill’s Color-Coded Tag System Works

Goodwill utilizes a simple color-coded tag system to price most items in their stores. Each color represents a specific price range that depends on the particular Goodwill location. Goodwill employees assign colored tags to items based on factors like brand, condition, and predicted demand. Popular colors used are:

Red Highest price items
Blue Mid-high price
Green Mid-low price
Yellow Lowest price

Some stores may use additional colors like orange, purple, pink, or black for special discount promotions. The color-coding allows customers to quickly gauge the price range of an item at a glance. Typically, higher-end brands and items in excellent condition will have red or blue tags, while run-of-the-mill used goods will be green or yellow.

Pricing Variations Between Locations

While the color-coded system is standard across all Goodwill stores, the actual prices assigned to each color vary from location to location. Goodwill is a decentralized organization, so pricing decisions are made at the regional or local level. Different geographic areas face unique economic conditions, competition, and donor profiles that require pricing flexibility.

For example, a red tag may indicate items over $10 in a small rural Goodwill. But in an upscale urban store, red may start at $25 or more. A blue tag could represent $3-$5 in one store and $6-$10 in another. Each store sets their own color pricing ranges based on what local shoppers are willing to pay.

Some general pricing tendencies:

  • Urban stores in higher-income areas tend to have higher prices than rural or suburban locations.
  • Shops in more fashion-focused cities like Los Angeles or New York usually price items higher than midwestern or southern stores.
  • Stores in areas with many thrifting outlets and secondhand shops often use lower pricing to compete for customers.

But again, final pricing decisions depend on the management at each location. The pricing levels are regularly evaluated and can change frequently to adapt to new conditions.

Why Pricing Varies

There are practical business reasons why Goodwill color tag prices are customized by location rather than following a uniform national pricing structure:

1. Account for regional economic variations

Income levels, wages, cost of living, and general prosperity differ greatly between geographic regions. Goodwill aims to price goods affordably within each local context so their customer base can afford to shop.

2. Reflect local supply and demand

Stores in areas with more limited vintage or used goods want to encourage ample donations. They keep prices lower so abundant inventory turns over quickly. Places with heavy donor supplies can price higher knowing stock moves fast.

3. Compete with local secondhand stores

Thrift and consignment stores thrive in some cities. Goodwill competes by adjusting strategy. Highly competitive markets use lower pricing to stand out. Areas without many thrift options can increase prices across colors.

4. Manage variable overhead costs

Factors like rent, labor, shipping, and utilities vary regionally. Local Goodwill leadership balances pricing against fixed costs. Higher-overhead stores may price higher to cover costs.

5. Respond quickly to changing conditions

Flexible localized pricing means stores can quickly drop or raise prices to spur sales based on the latest area trends and needs.

Pricing Consistency Within Regions

While pricing varies nationally, Goodwill strives for consistent color pricing across stores within defined regions. For example:

  • All stores in the Minneapolis/St. Paul metro likely use the same color prices.
  • Goodwills in the Dallas-Fort Worth area share pricing.
  • A similar structure operates in a given Ohio county or New York borough.

Keeping pricing aligned in neighboring stores maintains fairness for regional shoppers. Patrons can expect consistent deals when visiting multiple area locations. It also simplifies marketing and operations within territories.

Some examples of Goodwill regions with uniform pricing:

Dallas Metroplex Milwaukee Area
Greater Houston St. Louis Region
South Florida Suburban Maryland
Orange County, CA Greater Seattle

Of course, defining regions is not an exact science. Pricing may gradually change between different suburbs or city neighborhoods. But in general, clustered stores aim for cohesive pricing territory by territory.

Checking Local Price Levels

The best way to determine your local Goodwill’s current color pricing is to directly visit stores in your area. Check tags on various items to gauge the general ranges. Asking an employee is another good option – they know the latest pricing breaks. Also browse Goodwill’s online auctions, which display product colors and prices.

Some tips for researching in-store:

  • Note prices for red/blue/green/yellow tags on similar items
  • Compare men’s, women’s, home goods, electronics, and housewares
  • Visit a couple stores to cross-reference
  • Check the price tags of high-end brands vs. no-names
  • Ask a sales clerk what the color coding means

With a little in-person research, you’ll quickly learn the color pricing conventions near you.

Future Pricing Changes

Be aware that your local Goodwill may adjust their color pricing ranges periodically based on business needs. Some signs that prices are about to increase or decrease:

  • Sales volume is sluggish or inventory is too high
  • Shopper demand and foot traffic seems down
  • Competitor thrift stores recently changed pricing
  • Economic conditions and employment outlook shift
  • Holidays or seasonal sales are being planned

Stores often announce upcoming pricing realignments or place signage explaining changes. But staying on top of the latest prices requires periodically rechecking levels on tags in your area. Sign up for email newsletters from your Goodwill region so you’re notified of the latest sales or pricing updates.

Asking About Special Discounts

In addition to the standard color prices, Goodwill stores often run special discounts and promotions:

  • Half-off days for certain color tags
  • Seniors, student, teacher, or military discounts
  • Special weekend or holiday sales
  • Bargain outlet sections with slashed prices

Don’t be shy about asking staff what special deals or price reductions may be available during your visit. Letting Goodwill employees know you’re an frequent, budget-conscious shopper can unlock extra savings opportunities. Staff want to provide the best value to meet customers’ needs.

Maximizing Your Savings

Here are some pro tips for getting the very best deals when thrifting at Goodwill:

  • Bring a smartphone – Use it to quickly research item values and brands in the store. This helps identify when something is underpriced.
  • Ask about price adjustments – If an item seems overpriced based on condition, inquire if employees can reduce it.
  • Join the loyalty program – Many Goodwills offer ways to earn points and unlock special offers if you join their free membership program.
  • Follow on social media – Goodwill posts upcoming sales and store promotions on platforms like Facebook, Instagram and Twitter.
  • Go often – The more frequently you visit, the better you’ll learn pricing and recognize valuable hidden gems.
  • Check higher shelves – Sometimes the most deeply discounted items are placed up top or down low where they blend in.
  • Be friendly – Getting to know sales associates as a regular can lead to extra savings tips.
  • Time visits strategically – Stop by on discount days, crowds are lower, or new stock is being shelved for the best selection.

With the right preparation and shopping strategies, you can learn to master Goodwill’s color-coded pricing system and unlock outstanding savings.


While all Goodwills use color-coded tags to denote pricing ranges, the actual prices attached to each color do vary between regions and even neighboring locations. Local management sets pricing based on economic factors, store costs, inventory levels, and other business considerations. However, Goodwill strives to maintain consistent pricing across nearby stores so regional shoppers know what to expect. Through direct research and becoming a savvy thrifter, you can learn to find the very best deals within your area’s unique Goodwill color pricing structure. With clever shopping strategies and awareness of special discounts, the savings await at Goodwill.